Family owned & operated
The southern shores of Lake Ontario NY offer some of the finest freshwater fishing in the World for King Salmon (Chinook), brown trout, lake trout, steelhead/rainbow trout and coho salmon!
Come experience our amazing fishery with U.S. Coast Guard licensed Captain Jon Arena aboard his first class sport fishing vessel, the “Reel Em In”. Fish in total safety and comfort aboard this 33′ Trojan International Sportsfishing Yacht with heated and air conditioned cabin, full bath facilities and master suite.
The “Reel Em In” is also fully equipped with all the best in electronics to provide you with the most productive fishing trip possible! It features:
- 2 Lowrance color fish finders
- Lowrance GPS chartplotting navigational units
- 5 Scotty electric downriggers
- Ugly Stick Rods with Shimano & Penn Reels
- Raymarine Auto Pilot


For those of you who haven't experienced our fishery, here's what you can expect:
The open waters of Lake Ontario produce exceptional catches from April through October. It’s very common to land multiple species in an outing. We use different fishing tactics depending upon the time of year and location of the fish:
In Spring..
we use planer boards to get our lines out away from the boat, since the fish are in shallow water and very spooky. The “bite” is very close to the surface, and these fish are amazingly fresh and strong and acrobatic. They dart around, dance on the surface of the water and really put up a fight before they’ll let you . . . REEL EM IN!
Once the fish move into deeper water
we troll with downriggers along with multiple other tactics , which take our lines down to the depths where the fish are. When a fish hits, the downrigger “trips” and sets the hook automatically. Then it’s your job to . . . REEL EM IN!
As the season progresses..
the fish are putting on weight and gearing up for their Fall spawning runs. It’s not uncommon to have a 25 to 30 lb. King Salmon in your catch. These fish are amazingly strong – line screams off your reel as they make long runs away from the boat. And it’s a while before they’re tired enough to get them anywhere near a net! It’s a fight between the angler and the fish! Will you have enough strength left to . . . REEL EM IN??

Captain
Jon Arena
I’ve guided many successful fishing trips for more then 18 years professionally and have been fishing on Lake Ontario since I was a child. I’ve learned what it takes to consistently catch fish day in and day out. This is my full time job and how I make a living as well as my passion. I’ve fished with some of the best Captains on the Lake and from working with them along with my 25+ years of experience fishing on Lake Ontario I have developed a vast knowledge of both our fishery and of what it takes to consistently catch fish!
Additionally, my many years as an athlete taught me the self-discipline and dedication required to make your trip successful. I assure you that you will receive my maximum effort to provide you with a safe, enjoyable and productive day aboard the REEL EM IN!